At the Nativity display outside Faith Church of Lafayette, Indiana, the baby will be laid in a manger this year, surrounded by friendly beasts — except for the donkeys. They bite. In the past, the camels have been known to kick.
The church's Lafayette Living Nativity, which Faith has hosted since 1991, may be one of the few Christmas traditions that go off in usual fashion in a pandemic year.
"We've been practicing for this moment for the last 30 years," said the Rev. Steve Viars, senior pastor of Faith, who estimates that a quarter of a million visitors have attended the event in that time.
Live Nativities, in which visitors drive — and sometimes, especially in warmer climes, walk — through a number of scenes retelling the biblical story of Jesus' birth, have been popular around the U.S. for years. Actors from churches' congregations and, often, live animals are accompanied by narration of the story on a provided CD, accessed on smartphones via QR code or broadcast on a low-frequency transmitter.
Other churches offer a somewhat less "live" version that visitors can drive through, illustrating the story on painted backdrops.
All have found their moment in a year when mask wearing, social distancing and avoiding indoor gatherings have become the norm.
"People still need the message of Christmas, the true meaning, the hope and the love. And so how can we provide that for them in a safe way?" said the Rev. Jonathan Andersen, pastor of Harvest Point United Methodist Church in Locust Grove, Georgia, which is adapting its annual live Nativity, Return to Bethlehem, to share that story as safely as possible.
The church is shrinking the number of scenes and the length of the walking tour, in which guides lead small groups past a petting zoo and the city of Bethlehem, a semipermanent structure on the church's campus. The number of masked guests in each group will be limited and the total event will be held on two days, Dec. 12 and 13, not three. Prayer will move outside afterward, around campfires "in a distanced way," instead of ending inside the church.
This year, Andersen said, "The gift of it is everything's different and people are open to change."
The church also will give away a woodcut Christmas ornament instead of the usual hot chocolate. Church staff thought about engraving it with the year, but, after some thought about the past 12 months, Andersen said, laughing, "I think we're going to leave 2020 off the ornament."
The roadside live Nativity at Advent Lutheran Church, a congregation affiliated with the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America in Columbus, Ohio, is in its 50 year. At a busy, three-way intersection fronted by City Hall, the church and a golf course — the corner of "government, God and golf" — the event normally features coloring stations, hot chocolate and performances by the Singing Buckeyes, a men's a capella group, according to the Rev. Aaron Layne.
The surrounding county has been hard hit by the coronavirus, and Columbus is under a stay-at-home advisory. But, the pastor said, that doesn't mean Christmas is canceled.
Advent Lutheran has pushed back its event to Dec. 23, after the order lifts, and it has expanded its single manger scene, starring a donkey named Shrek, to six drive-thru scenes from the Christmas story on its property.
The church has tried to be thoughtful about creating scenes with one safely distanced actor, like Mary delivering the Magnificat, as well as scenes that can be performed by a single household: a family of six will hold down the scene in which a multitude of the heavenly host appears to shepherds.
"Honestly, there's disappointment and beauty in it all at the same time," Layne said.
"I think it serves as a reminder that nothing — not sin, not COVID-19, not years like 2020 — can stop God's love from coming and being with us," he said. "Christmas is God's love and salvation and word made flesh, and, you know, that doesn't stop. In fact, I think it's more important to do that now."
In neighboring Indiana, Faith has cut some scenes from its Lafayette Living Nativity to accommodate more cars since it's done away with its usual walk-through option. Over the years, it has expanded to recount not only the birth of Jesus, but the Garden of Eden story and Jesus' death, resurrection and second coming. Hundreds of people, as well as camels, donkeys and sheep, now make up the cast.
"It's just been a delightful way for us to proclaim the gospel at Christmastime," Viars said.
"This year, there's no question that there's a hunger for truth. There's a hunger for joy. There's a hunger for a message that you can rely on in these uncertain times, but also just fun family activities that are safe."
And, in true 2020 fashion, Mary, Joseph and the rest will be wearing face masks. "The nice thing about doing it in Lafayette in the wintertime is you need a mask, you need a scarf, so you're bundled up anyway," Viars said.
The biting donkeys may get masks, too.
"It might be comeuppance time for the donkeys in 2020," he said.