'A church for the poor should not be poorly managed'

Cardinal George Pell stands on the balcony outside his office in St. John's Tower overlooking St. Peter's Basilica. (CNS/Robert Duncan)

"Vatican reformers have discovered hundreds of millions of euros that did not appear on the Holy See's balance sheet," said Cardinal George Pell, the Australian conservative Pope Francis chose earlier this year to put the Vatican's finances in order.

Arcane accounting practices and fiercely guarded departmental independence have kept "some hundreds of millions of euros ... tucked away in particular sectional accounts," Pell wrote in The Catholic Herald, a weekly publication from the United Kingdom.

The Vatican's finances are much healthier than many thought, Pell writes. "It is important to point out that the Vatican is not broke. Apart from the pension fund, which needs to be strengthened for the demands on it in 15 or 20 years, the Holy See is paying its way, while possessing substantial assets and investments."

In February, Pope Francis created a new Council of the Economy to monitor all economic and administrative activities of the Holy See. The makeup of the council is unique: Instead of being dominated by Italian prelates, seven of the council's 15 members are laypeople -- experts in finance -- and they come from a variety of nationalities.

To carry out the guidelines of the council and provide the administrative oversight, Francis also created the Secretariat of the Economy and appointed Pell its president.

As part of the broader administrative reform, in November, Pell released a 45-page manual, "Financial Management Policies," that spelled out new rules for budgeting and financial reporting that all Vatican offices must follow beginning Jan. 1.

The intent of the manual is to modernize and internationalize the Vatican bureaucracy while reducing its overall size, improving a "checks and balances" system to increase transparency and increasing oversight by laypeople.

Writing in the Herald, Pell said, "Donors expect their gifts to be handled efficiently and honestly, so that the best returns are achieved to finance the works of the Church, especially those aimed at preaching the Gospel and helping the poor escape from poverty. A Church for the poor should not be poorly managed."

Earlier, Catholic News Service published an extended interview with Pell: "Pope's finance chief talks Vatican reform."

In the CNS interview, Pell said Pope Francis wants a "poor church for the poor," but that "doesn't necessarily mean a church with empty coffers, and it certainly doesn't mean a church that is sloppy or inefficient or open to being robbed."

Join the Conversation

Send your thoughts and reactions to Letters to the Editor. Learn more here