Agana, Guam — No matter the outcome of a Vatican trial against Guam's archbishop, Archbishop Anthony S. Apuron of Agana should not return to lead the archdiocese, said the archdiocese's coadjutor.
"I think it would be a disaster if Archbishop Apuron were to return as the bishop of record," said Coadjutor Archbishop Michael J. Byrnes, because of the extent of the loss of trust among the faithful and the "widespread disarray" left behind in church operations.
Byrnes, a former auxiliary bishop of Detroit, spoke to the press in Agana July 6, offering an update of the canonical investigation and trial of Apuron and his own personal thoughts about what would be best for the archdiocese moving forward.
U.S. Cardinal Raymond L. Burke, a church law expert and former head of the Vatican's highest court, led a Vatican team to Guam in February to investigate allegations of sexual abuse leveled against Apuron.
Three men have publicly accused the archbishop of sexually abusing them when they were altar boys in the 1970s. The mother of a fourth man, now deceased, also accused the archbishop of abusing her son.
Work at NCR!
Seniors and recent college graduates may apply to be the next Bertelsen Editorial Intern. Learn more about this opportunity.
Byrnes said the Vatican trial was in its final phases.
"In the next several weeks," three judges will convene at the Vatican to deliberate the evidence gathered during the investigation, publish what the accusations were and then decide among three possibilities: "not guilty, guilty or not proven," he said. It could be "end of summer, early fall," or later for the Vatican to release its decision, he added.
Asked if the archbishop was also being charged for financial mismanagement, not just alleged child abuse, Byrnes told reporters he did not know what the charges ended up being, but that they would be published eventually after the Vatican judges deliberated.
Byrnes said even if his predecessor is found "not guilty" of any charges, it would be unwise to let the archbishop return.
"I think and I'm convinced, actually, that this archdiocese would be unable to achieve peace, really, until it's clear that Archbishop Apuron is no longer the bishop of record of this diocese. And I don't say this on the basis of the trial, I say this on the basis of my experience here, what I have found in the last seven months," ministering to and serving the church there, he said.
While he did not want to provide any details about what he found, he said, "There was a very widespread disarray and ineffectiveness of many of the operations that you'd expect to be going on in a regular archdiocese."
"Some of the consultative bodies were not being utilized in the way they should've been used. Some of the policies that had been around for a long time, for instance the sexual abuse policy, was sorely lacking in its bite, in its clarity of a solid process to deal with these kinds of things," he said.
"So, in other words," he said, "I think it would be a disaster if Archbishop Apuron were to return."
"There's been a tremendous loss of trust that's really hard to win back," he said during a question-and-answer session. The loss of trust will demand hard work and greater transparency and having Apuron return even if nothing is proven or he's found not guilty "would just, I think, exacerbate this loss of trust" in the church.
Archbishop Savio Hon Tai-Fai, the former apostolic administrator of the Agana Archdiocese, requested that, in light of the allegations and investigation, the Vatican remove Apuron and name a successor. When Apuron refused to resign, Pope Francis appointed Byrnes to lead the archdiocese as coadjutor.
"I feel that the sentiment of a lot of the faithful is 'We need something different, something new,'" Byrnes said.
"The past has to become the past so that we are able to move forward in peace and continue the real building of the church" and doing what Catholics depend on the church to do, "even on the nitty gritty, administrative, financial, pastoral infrastructure of the island," he said.
"I've already seen come great changes, we've got awesome people with great hearts, but it's going to take a lot," he said.
Join the Conversation
Send your thoughts and reactions to our online Letters to the Editor column. Learn more here