German archbishop says US-Mexico border wall recalls Berlin Wall, warns against loss of humanity

Touring the U.S.-Mexico border between Ciudad Juárez, Mexico, and El Paso, Texas, Archbishop Stefan Hesse of Hamburg said the towering fortifications and razor wire dividing the two border communities evoked a painful memory in his own country’s history: the Berlin Wall.

"In a way, the inhumanity and massiveness of these border fortifications reminded me of the Berlin Wall, which divided the German capital for nearly 30 years and caused great suffering for the people living there," Hesse told OSV News in an Aug. 31 interview.

"I found the border situation to be disturbing," added the archbishop, who serves as chairman of the German bishops’ conference's migration commission. "Two cities that had essentially grown together into one — and whose populations remain connected in many ways -- are now hermetically separated by a border wall and razor wire."

Hesse embarked on an Aug. 20-27 "solidarity trip" to assess the humanitarian reality along key migration routes, the German bishops' conference said in a statement published Aug. 20.

Also serving as the conference's special envoy for refugee issues, the archbishop has embarked on similar trips in past years, including Ukraine, Kenya and Egypt. During his visit, Hesse met migrants, volunteers, aid agency representatives, civil and church leaders, including Bishop Mark Seitz of El Paso, immediate past chairman of the U.S. bishops’ Committee on Migration.

Seitz and Dylan Corbett, executive director of the Hope Border Institute, a migrant advocacy agency based in El Paso, hosted the archbishop's delegation.

Recalling his visit to Mexico, Hesse told OSV News that, due to restrictive U.S. policies, the country that was once "a country of origin and transit" has now become "a destination country for migrants" and is also facing additional challenges from deportations "out of the U.S."

The German prelate said he was struck by two distinct encounters, one "with an elderly gentleman from Cuba whom I met at the church-run Albergue Belén (“Bethlehem Shelter”) in Tapachula."

"He lived and worked in the U.S. for 46 years, was well integrated, and has now been deported to southern Mexico — to a region he doesn’t know and where he has little prospect of a dignified life in his old age. His fate is like that of a tree that has been uprooted," he said.

The second was with a young man from Ciudad Juárez who, at a young age, was involved in organized crime and had also worked as a "smuggler" who guided people along the treacherous border.

"The young man told me with remarkable openness how, with the help of his faith, he finally managed to escape the clutches of organized crime. Now he is involved in a project that helps young migrants find their way in Mexico," the archbishop said.

Hesse told OSV News that amid the suffering of those along the border, he had heard and witnessed that "without the church's services, the situation would be much worse."

"Approximately 80% of the shelters are run by the church. There, refugees and migrants not only receive a roof over their heads but are also treated with dignity as human beings," he said.

One such example, he noted, was the CAFEMIN shelter run by the Sisters of St. Joseph in Mexico City, who "truly brings Pope Francis’s four verbs to life: welcoming, protecting, promoting and integrating migrants."

However, the archbishop also noticed that there is a "wide gulf" between Christian shelters that are "centered on the dignity of every single person" and detention centers "where migrants are primarily viewed as a threat."

"Certainly, it is the state’s responsibility to regulate migration. But during my trip to Mexico and the U.S., I also witnessed what happens when migration is treated exclusively as a security issue: A fundamental sense of humanity ends up being lost," he told OSV News.