Benedict XVI's July 8-9
trip to Valencia, Spain, offered a classic illustration of the dilemma
facing popes when it comes to secular politics, an arena in which they are
almost literally damned if they do, damned if they don't. If they take a
stand, they risk being accused of interference in the secular sphere; if
they don't, critics will complain about their silence.
The solution modern popes have embraced is to speak in generalities
that usually leave little doubt as to their mind, but avoiding direct
statements about particular politicians, governments, or debates. That's
just what Benedict did during his brief, 26-hour trip to Valencia, Spain,
for the close of the fifth Vatican-sponsored "World Meeting of Families."
Media interest was fueled by a showdown between Benedict and the
Socialist Prime Minister, José Luis Rodr'guez Zapatero, whose full-court
press in favor of gay marriage, embryonic stem cell research, divorce, and
a wide variety of other issues has created church/state tensions not seen
since the Spanish Civil War.
Benedict XVI did not mince words in articulating the church's
traditional vision of the family and of human sexuality.
This week, we celebrate the first anniversary of the launch of our podcast, NCR in Conversation. Catch the latest episode here.
"Attempts are being made to organize the life of society on the basis
of subjective and ephemeral desires alone, with no reference to objective,
prior truths such as the dignity of each human being and his inalienable
rights and duties, which every social group is called to serve," the pope
said in a Sunday morning Mass attended by one and a half million people.
In a similar vein, Benedict exhorted the Spanish bishops to
"dauntlessly proclaim that prescinding from God, acting as if he did not
exist or relegating faith to the purely private sphere, undermines the
truth about man and compromises the future of culture and society."
Such language induced some observers to see Benedict's trip largely as
an anti-Zapatero protest. Crowd reaction fueled that impression, since
whenever Zapatero made an appearance, he drew lusty "boos" and acerbic
chants. (One example: Banners were hung in Valencia in the days leading up
to Benedict's arrival saying "We're waiting for you." When Zapatero
arrived at the archbishop's palace for his meeting with the pope, the
crowd began to shout, "Zapatero, we're not waiting for you!")
Yet Benedict is also an instinctively gracious figure, who was never
going to engage in the sort of verbal fisticuffs many expected.
The pope met not only with Zapatero but also with his top deputy, Mar'a
Teresa Fernández de la Vega, and both sides later described the encounter
as friendly and productive. Indeed, Spanish sources told NCR that
after his chat with Fernández de la Vega, the pope told her that he felt
church/state relations in Spain are "in good hands."
Benedict also resisted the temptation to "go negative," ducking
invitations to specifically excoriate Zapatero's policies. Asked by
reporters on the papal plane about the gay marriage law, for example,
Benedict said he didn't want to start off with negative things, but
preferred to focus on the many healthy and happy families "which give us
hope for the future," before going on to restate that marriage is based on
an indissoluble bond between a man and a woman.
Beyond disagreements with Zapatero, the pope also realized there's
business to be done in other areas.
Spanish sources told NCR that negotiations between Cardinal
Antonio Cañizares Llovera of Toledo, representing the Spanish bishops, and
Fernández de la Vega seem to be making progress on two especially thorny
issues: the question of teaching religion in public schools, and of public
funding for church activities.
Benedict did not want to engage in rhetorical fireworks that might
disrupt those talks, or shut down the possibility of future conversation
on other matters.
The price of such a balancing act is that it leaves partisans on both
sides unsatisfied. Those sympathetic to Zapatero resented what they saw as
an overtly political tone to the trip, while the Prime Minister's most
dogged Catholic critics wished the pope would have more publicly taken him
to the woodshed.
Yet most Spaniards with whom I spoke seemed to feel Benedict had made
"In my opinion, the pope was very direct, very clear," said Maria
Mendez, 44, a mother of eight who told NCR she had traveled from
Madrid in part "to support the pope."
"He didn't need to mention Zapatero by name," Mendez said.
* * *
Such analysis risks the impression that Benedict's agenda in Valencia
was basically political, when the pope sees himself far more as a pastor
and a catechist than a politician. His primary message was not a call to
barricades against the Socialists, but rather that the traditional
Christian conception of the family is the best path to human flourishing.
"Lifting one's gaze to the living God, the garantor of our freedom and
of truth, is a premise for arriving at a new humanity," he said in the
In a "Festival of Families" Saturday night, he returned to the theme.
"We have gathered here from so many parts of the world as a community
which with gratitude and joy bears witness that human beings were created
in the image and likeness of God for love, and that complete human
fulfillment only comes about when we make a sincere gift of ourselves to
others," he said.
The heart of Benedict's argument was expressed in this paragraph from
his Saturday text.
"Christian faith and ethics are not meant to stifle love, but to make
it healthier, stronger and more truly free," he said. "Human love needs to
be purified and to mature if it is to be fully human and the principle of
a true and lasting joy."
At what one might call the "retail" pastoral level, Benedict was
concerned with broadening the conception of the family beyond the nuclear
unit of parents and children, giving attention especially to the role of
In his remarks Saturday night, Pope Benedict included a special appeal
for grandparents, urging that "in no way should they ever be excluded from
the family circle."
Before the pope spoke, a series of families from different parts of the
world offered brief "testimonies." Italian actor Lino Banfi, best known
for his role as a grandfather in the popular series Un Medico in
Famiglia, told Benedict that some people call the actor "Italy's
Banfi said that he responds, "If I'm the grandfather of Italy, then our
pope is the grandfather of the world!"
During Sunday's Mass, Benedict returned to the theme, insisting that
families must be understood as including "not only parents and children,
but also grandparents and ancestors."
"The family thus appears to us as a community of generations and the
guarantee of a patrimony of traditions," the pope said.
Just $5 a month supports NCR's independent Catholic journalism.
We are committed to keeping our online journalism open and available to as many readers as possible. To do that, we need your help. Join NCR Forward, our new membership program.
Looking for comments?
We've suspended comments on NCRonline.org for a while. If you missed that announcement, learn more about our decision here.