Over at Crisis Magazine, which one would want to describe as an intellectual mouthpiece for RC neo-cons but hesitates to do so while it persists in publishing intellectual drivel, has an article up by Nicholas G. Hahn III in which Mr. Hahn attacks the bishops for their "immigration obsession." His nose is out of joint because the USCCB has a special part of its website educating Catholics on the justice of the DREAM Act and the need for comprehensive immigration reform. Hahn believes that, having failed to evangelize our own, the bishops are trying to "replace" US Catholics with immigrant Catholics. He urges them to abandon the cause.
There is too much bile in Hahn's article to refute, but I will only call attention to his most absurd, and central, claim. He writes:
It is unclear to me why Hahn sees changing the culture from within as mutually exclusive of welcoming immigrants. Indeed, immigration is one of the principal ways America has always changed from within. More importantly, one of the ways you change a culture from within is by calling it to justice. One of the ways Catholics can change our U.S. culture from within is by standing up for the proposition that parents should not be separated from their families, nor husbands from their wives, as happens far too frequently when our current immigration laws are enforced. What is "selfish" about standing up for justice and the traditional family?
I must say that Hahn's snarling piece is one of the worst pieces I have ever read at Crisis magazine, and that is saying a lot. Me? I hope the bishops stay plenty "obsessed" about immigration.
Looking for comments?
We've suspended comments on NCRonline.org for a while. If you missed that announcement, learn more about our decision here.