I was having a tiresome conversation with a rising second-grader (my grandson) about the four elements.
He told me they were earth, air, fire and ice. I told him that they were earth, air, fire and water, and that ice was a derivative of water. He patronized me about how awful it was that I had been educated in the Pleistocene period. Clearly, the four elements were earth, air, fire and ice. He even hauled out the Disney movie "Frozen" and added its importance to his well-armored evidence.
I switched the subject, suggesting that the more important question was about the meaning of the word elemental, not how many elements there were. I told him that the kind of school he goes to used to be called "elementary," as in elementary school, a wonderful way of describing the basics and the foundational nature of children's education. I tried to get an audience for the three R's but that was way too high a hope. I told him the word elemental was like the word fundamental — and it meant what is really important, like the four elements.
Then I sprung my developmentally appropriate question. What is most important about fire? He knew right away, having missed the course in modesty early on: "It's knowing how to start a fire and how to put one out." I think he's right.
What is elementary is knowing when to praise and when to protest, when to complain and when to invite, when to criticize and when to appreciate, when to say a loud "yes" to the future instead of a loud "no" to the past.
A month ago, we passed the 15th anniversary of what is now reduced to a conglomeration of tragedies, experiences, heroism and long-lasting impact called 9/11. Many of us would like to know how to put out that fire. We'd like to know how to get beyond working on terrorism and to start working on fossil fuel replacements. We'd like to stop fighting and start building. The biggest threat to the environment may be human and religious discord, which keeps us fighting rather than tending.
I like relaxing with a catalog every now and then. While browsing a copy of Hammacher Schlemmer, "America's oldest catalog," recently, I arrived at this description of an exclusive product: "This is the baseball cap with an inconspicuous camera that records high definition video." It made me pause, a reminder of terrorism or police violence in the midst of my shopping experience. I don't want to live in a world where I need self-protective personal headwear or have to buy it through luxury outlets.
I also wonder why so many of us are so addicted to our cellphones. Maybe they are also a derivative of 9/11? I've asked people why they are so connected to their cells. "Because if something happens, I want to be able to call someone." I do understand that. There is a kind of ghost safety in that being able to call. And many of us will take just about any safety we can get.
Our preoccupation with the old ways and the old days and the hurt already accumulated — and not released — has resulted in a lack of attention to earth and her glad ways. What if we need another reformation, one which stops the hurting and starts the healing?
On Oct. 31, the 500th anniversary of the Protestant Reformation, we're going to have a special service at Judson. It will memorialize those great 500 years. It will also be a celebration of the beginning of the first year of the next reformation.
In that year we are going to begin to put out the fire of interreligious hate. You know it well. You know it in impossible conversations about Israel and Palestine, and the havoc it is wreaking in the Black Lives Matter movement. The fire that is burning from hate between religions is out of control. We need to learn how to put it out.
We also need to learn how to spark a new religion, or not a completely new religion, but a reform for this historical moment. As important as it is to learn how to put fires out, there is also the question of starting fires and tending fires. We need to tend our environment and not just our human interactions and their difficulties. We need a new religion that respects nature as much as pagans did — and respects human agency as the current religions do. As any nature lover knows, it often takes a couple of hours rubbing two sticks — not two humans — together to get to a spark.
I imagine sparking a new fire and adding all the twigs I can find to that fire. Solar energy. Wind energy. Taxing fossil fuels even more deeply. Wearing baseball caps that don't have built-in cameras. Gathering in public spaces without fear and tons of security.
Maybe if we starve the old fights of oxygen and twigs, we will find the mental space to think anew. We may even find ourselves knee deep in a new reformation, the first year of which needed to start with yesterday. Elementary care of earth, air, fire, water — and ice — will help us be wonderful beginners at a new kind of religion and a new kind of earth.
[Donna Schaper is senior minister of Judson Memorial Church in New York City.]
Editor's note: Want more stories from Eco Catholic? We can send you an email alert once a week with the latest. Just go to this page and follow directions: Email alert sign-up.
Just $5 a month supports NCR's independent Catholic journalism.
We are committed to keeping our online journalism open and available to as many readers as possible. To do that, we need your help. Join NCR Forward, our new membership program.
Looking for comments?
We've suspended comments on NCRonline.org for a while. If you missed that announcement, learn more about our decision here.