Anderson invites Biden to talk about abortion views

WASHINGTON -- Carl A. Anderson, supreme knight of the Knights of Columbus, wants to talk with Sen. Joseph Biden, the Democratic vice-presidential candidate.

In a full-page advertisement that appeared in several newspapers Sept. 19, Anderson said he wants to discuss only one issue: Biden's stance on abortion and his unwillingness to bring his Catholic views into the discussion of public policy on the issue.

"I hope that he will really consider this (meeting)," Anderson told Catholic News Service Sept. 19. "I hope that he will read Pope John Paul (II)'s 'Evangelium Vitae' ('The Gospel of Life'). That document, maybe more than any other, is the heart of the teaching of the church about respect for human life."

Appearing in the Washington Times, the Philadelphia Inquirer, the News Journal in Wilmington, Del., the Times-Tribune in Scranton, Pa., the Citizens' Voice in Wilkes-Barre, Pa., and the Baltimore and Washington editions of USA Today, the ad comes in response to Biden's Sept. 7 appearance on NBC's "Meet the Press."

During an interview with host Tom Brokaw, the Delaware senator said he accepted Catholic teaching that life begins at conception but that he could not impose his beliefs in the public policy arena.

"I'm prepared as a matter of faith to accept that life begins at the moment of conception," Biden said during the interview. "But that is my judgment. For me to impose that judgment on everyone else who is equally and maybe even more devout than I am seems to me is inappropriate in a pluralistic society."

Biden supported his view by citing the 13th-century writings of St. Thomas Aquinas, who discussed when a developing child in the womb received a soul and thus could be considered fully human.

Anderson's letter is the most recent response related to Catholic politicians addressing church teaching on abortion in national venues. Within days of Biden's appearance on the NBC broadcast, several Catholic bishops responded with their own statements challenging the senator's views.

See also: Catholic Democrat group hits K of C attack on Biden.

The letter also interjects the Knights of Columbus into presidential politics and a campaign where the Catholic vote is being sought fervently by the Democratic ticket of Sen. Barack Obama and Biden and the Republican ticket of Sen. John McCain and Gov. Sarah Palin.

"Our intention isn't to enter the political fray," Anderson told CNS. "It really is to address a matter within the Catholic community about how this issue ought to be understood.

"I would be much more interested in having a dispassionate discussion of this where it doesn't affect political careers. But I'm not the one who's chosen to interject this issue in this way at this time," the supreme knight added.

Anderson opened his letter by addressing Biden as a "fellow Catholic layman." The supreme knight wrote that by virtue of Biden's position as a vice-presidential candidate, any statements he makes will "carry considerable weight, whether they are correct or not."

The letter sets forth a case regarding the Thomist understanding of human development, saying the writings of the saint were based on a medieval understanding of biology and that he could only speculate on how an unborn child develops in the womb.

"I doubt that there is any other area of public policy where you would appeal to a 13th-century knowledge of biology as the basis for modern law," Anderson wrote to Biden.

Regardless of the Thomist view on when an unborn child receives a soul, the letter contends that the saint adhered to long-standing church teaching in opposition to abortion.

"Statements that suggest that our church has anything less than a consistent teaching on abortion are not merely incorrect; they may lead Catholic women facing crisis pregnancies to misunderstand the moral gravity of an abortion decision," Anderson said in the letter.

Anderson also said it was the religious conviction of people that motivated them to confront slavery in the 19th century and to work for civil rights in the 20th century. In much the same way, Anderson said, people of faith must work to overturn the abortion laws of the United States.

"On behalf of the 1.28 million members of the Knights of Columbus and their families in the United States, I appeal to you, as a Catholic who acknowledges that life begins at conception, to resolve to protect this unalienable right," Anderson concluded.

- - -

Editor's Note: The Knights of Columbus ad can be viewed online at Open Letter to Sen. Joseph Biden.

Join the Conversation

Send your thoughts and reactions to Letters to the Editor. Learn more here