Cardinal Wuerl wrote papal nuncio of abuse claims against McCarrick in 2004

Cardinal Donald Wuerl, apostolic administrator of the Washington Archdiocese, center, attends a prayer service in the Chapel of the Immaculate Conception at Mundelein Seminary Jan. 2 at the University of St. Mary of the Lake in Illinois, near Chicago. (CNS/Bob Roller)

by Catholic News Service

View Author Profile

Join the Conversation

Send your thoughts to Letters to the Editor. Learn more

Church officials confirmed that Cardinal Donald Wuerl, retired archbishop of Washington, had forwarded an allegation of sexual misconduct against his predecessor, former Cardinal Theodore McCarrick, to the papal nuncio in Washington in 2004.

In a Jan. 10 statement, the Archdiocese of Washington said Wuerl, who at the time was bishop of Pittsburgh, "received no further information regarding the matter" involving the former cardinal.

The Diocese of Pittsburgh in a statement emailed to Catholic News Service Jan. 11 confirmed that then-Bishop Wuerl informed the papal nuncio, Archbishop Gabriel Montalvo, in 2004 of the allegation against the former cardinal.

Wuerl's action came after Robert Ciolek, a former priest of the Diocese of Metuchen, New Jersey, filed a complaint with the Pittsburgh Diocese saying he had been abused as a seminarian by a Pittsburgh priest. The abuse was alleged to have occurred by the priest assigned to the faculty of Mount St. Mary's Seminary in Emmitsburg, Maryland, where Ciolek was studying at the time, the Washington Archdiocese said.

During a November 2004 appearance before the Independent Review Board of the Pittsburgh Diocese to discuss the incident involving the priest, Ciolek also addressed his alleged abuse by McCarrick in New Jersey, according to the diocese's statement. "This was the first time the Diocese of Pittsburgh learned of this allegation," the statement said.

Ciolek sought confidentiality at the time, both the Washington Archdiocese and Pittsburgh Diocese said.

After notifying Montalvo, Wuerl "adhered to Mr. Ciolek's request for confidentiality," the Washington Archdiocese's statement said.

McCarrick resigned as a cardinal in July 2018 after public reports of alleged sexual misconduct involving seminarians and a minor.

Ciolek asked the Pittsburgh Diocese for permission to review the file containing his complaint and during his review in December he discovered the file shows that Wuerl knew of his allegations against McCarrick, The Washington Post reported Jan. 10.

He subsequently approached the newspaper with his findings.

During the summer as the reports of McCarrick's alleged misconduct became public, Wuerl denied knowing of any complaints against the former archbishop of Washington.

The Washington Archdiocese's statement, however, said Wuerl was referring to claims of sexual abuse of a minor by McCarrick.

"Cardinal Wuerl has attempted to be accurate in addressing questions about Archbishop McCarrick," the archdiocese said, adding "the cardinal stands by those statements, which were not intended to be imprecise."

The archdiocese said neither it nor Wuerl was aware that Ciolek had reached a settlement with the Diocese of Metuchen over the abuse claim. The Pittsburgh Diocese's statement said it did not learn it was included in the settlement until July 2018.

Ciolek told The Washington Post that even though he earlier wanted to remain unnamed, Wuerl could have acknowledged last summer what he knew about the allegations involving McCarrick.

McCarrick had been bishop of the Metuchen Diocese from June 1982 until July 1986, when he was installed as archbishop of the Archdiocese of Newark, New Jersey.

"It is important to note that Archbishop Theordore McCarrick was appointed to the Archdiocese of Washington in November 2000 and named a cardinal in February 2001, years before Mr. Ciolek made his claims. Then-Bishop Wuerl was not involved in the decision-making process resulting in the appointment and promotion," the archdiocese's statement said.

"In June 2006, Bishop Wuerl was named archbishop of Washington. Cardinal Wuerl has said that until the accusation of abuse of a minor by Cardinal McCarrick was made in New York, no one from this archdiocese had come forward with an accusation of abuse by Archbishop McCarrick during his time in Washington," the statement added.

Pope Francis accepted Wuerl's resignation in October 2018. Now 78, the cardinal submitted his resignation, as is mandatory, to the pope when he turned 75 in November 2016, but it was not accepted for nearly two years.

An August 2018 Pennsylvania grand jury report detailing 70 years of allegations sex abuse by priests and other church workers in six Catholic dioceses of the state, beginning in 1947 brought calls for Wuerl to step down as Washington's archbishop. The issue was how abuse cases had been dealt with during his years as bishop of Pittsburgh, one of the six dioceses covered by the report.

Vatican officials are investigating the misconduct allegations against McCarrick and have heard testimony from his accusers.

McCarrick, who has denied allegations against him, now lives in a Capuchin Franciscan friary in Victoria, Kansas.

Latest News


1x per dayDaily Newsletters
1x per weekWeekly Newsletters
2x WeeklyBiweekly Newsletters