Weigel in JPII Heaven

by Michael Sean Winters

View Author Profile

Join the Conversation

Send your thoughts to Letters to the Editor. Learn more

George Weigel's article at InsideCatholic "Remembering Pope John Paul II," begins with the reminder, as if any were needed, that Weigel spent more time with the late pontiff than you did. As one Vatican official said to me when Weigel's biography of John Paul II came out, "After reading it, one is left with the question: Who is that man standing in white next to George Weigel?"

Here Weigel makes the point that "everything he did was the accomplishment of a radically converted Christian disciple." I do not doubt that the Pope was a disciple, even a "radically converted one" but it also seems to me that Pope John Paul II was a more complicated figure than his hero-worshipping biographer makes him out to be. We certainly know he wasa deplorable judge of character as witness by the corruption of those he placed in positions of authority. We know that Pope John Paul II - and Weigel - praised Father Maciel and held up the Legionaries as a model for the future of the Church. I will set aside the question whether Weigel's ignorance of Maciel's misdeeds was willful or not, but he knows that now and surely, the details of Maciel's dealings with Pope John Paul II and his inner circle must make anyone cringe. That does not make John Paul II less saintly in my book, it makes him more human, but Weigel prefers a cardboard cutout hero to a real person with real flaws.

Weigel's other point in this article, linking the beatification's falling on Divine Mercy Sunday with the cultural inability of the West to find forgiveness and mercy for its many sins, is more salient. Of course, Weigel does not push the obvious point: The devotion to Divine Mercy is quite at odds with the tenor and flavor of today's American conservatives with their protean, Ayn Rand-worshipping, poor-bashing social Darwinism.

Why anyone publishes George Weigel is beyond me. There is not a less interesting writer on the planet and, sad to say, he seems hell-bent on making his hero, John Paul II, as boring as himself. It is too grim.

More NCR coverage of the beatification of John Paul II

Maureen Fiedler: Beatifications and Politics
Michael Baxter: Biography of JPII raises questions about partiality
Michael Sean Winters: Weigel in JPII Heaven
John L. Allen Jr.: In death as in life, John Paul a sign of contradiction
Gerald Slevin John Paul beatification highlights dysfunctional monarchy

John Allen's Beatification Q&As
#1: What's the Rush?
#2: What’s the deal with miracles?
#3: Why make saints out of popes?
#4: What’s the Divine Mercy connection?

Latest News


1x per dayDaily Newsletters
1x per weekWeekly Newsletters
2x WeeklyBiweekly Newsletters